Lab Grown Diamond Education
Diamond Education
Lab Grown or Natural?
Both are real diamonds. Neither one is a compromise, and neither one is automatically the better buy. What separates them is where they came from, what they cost, and what happens to their value afterward. Here is the honest comparison, so you can decide which matters to you.
Also in this series: Understanding Natural Diamonds · All Diamond Education
First, What They Have in Common
A laboratory grown diamond has essentially the same chemical, physical and optical properties as a natural one. Both are crystallized carbon. Both sit at 10 on the Mohs scale, the hardest natural substance known. Both throw the same light, take the same cuts, and wear the same way over a lifetime. A jeweler cannot tell them apart by eye or with a loupe, and neither can anyone looking at your hand. Separating them takes specialized laboratory equipment.
So when someone asks whether a lab grown diamond is a "real diamond," the answer is yes. It is not a simulant. Cubic zirconia and moissanite are different materials that imitate the look of diamond. A lab grown diamond is diamond.
| Natural | Lab Grown | |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Crystallized carbon | Crystallized carbon |
| Hardness | 10 on the Mohs scale | 10 on the Mohs scale |
| Appearance | Indistinguishable to the eye, to a loupe, and to a standard diamond tester | |
| Origin | Formed in the earth over roughly one to three billion years, brought up by volcanic activity | Grown in a matter of weeks by HPHT or CVD, using a diamond seed |
| Supply | Finite. Each stone is geologically unique and cannot be reproduced | Producible on demand. Capacity continues to expand |
| Price | Higher, and relatively stable over time | Substantially lower, and has fallen considerably as production has scaled |
| Resale | An established secondary market exists, though resale is still typically well below retail | Very limited resale market. Expect little to nothing back |
| Identification | Requires specialized lab equipment. Most stones are laser inscribed on the girdle with their report number | |
The Case for Natural
- It is geologically finite. Nobody can make more of it, and that scarcity is the entire basis of its pricing.
- Value holds up far better. It is not an investment, but it does not fall off a cliff either.
- There is a mature resale, trade-in and estate market. We buy natural diamonds; almost nobody buys lab grown.
- For heirloom pieces meant to be handed down, provenance and long-term worth tend to matter more.
- Some people simply want the billion-year story. That is a legitimate reason to buy something.
The Case for Lab Grown
- You get dramatically more size and quality for the same budget. That is the whole point, and it is a real advantage.
- A larger center stone or a higher clarity grade becomes reachable at a price that would not otherwise allow it.
- Nobody will ever look at your ring and know, because there is nothing to know. It is diamond.
- For fashion pieces, studs, anniversary bands and anything you might want to restyle later, resale value rarely enters into it.
- If the budget is fixed and the look is the priority, this is usually the more rational choice.
Where the Honest Answer Is "It Depends"
Environmental impact. Both sides market hard on this and neither claim survives much scrutiny. Diamond mining has a real land, water and energy footprint. Growing diamonds is also energy intensive, and how clean that energy is depends entirely on the grid where the facility sits. Anyone telling you one is definitively the green choice is selling something. If this genuinely drives your decision, ask for specifics about the individual producer or mine rather than accepting a category-wide claim.
Ethical sourcing. The natural diamond trade has spent decades building traceability, and reputable suppliers can document a stone's chain of custody. That system is not perfect. Lab grown avoids mining entirely, which sidesteps the question rather than answering it, since labor and energy conditions at growing facilities vary too. Both deserve real questions rather than a slogan.
Future pricing. Lab grown prices have dropped substantially as capacity has grown. Where they settle from here is genuinely unknown. Treat any confident prediction, in either direction, with suspicion.
Reading the Paperwork
Both types are graded by independent laboratories, but the reports are not interchangeable. GIA issues a separate Laboratory-Grown Diamond Report that describes color and clarity in broader categories rather than the D-to-Z color scale and abbreviated clarity grades used for natural diamonds. Grading conventions also differ from lab to lab, so a grade from one is not always directly comparable to the same-sounding grade from another.
Practical advice: always ask which laboratory issued the report, and compare stones graded by the same lab. Any diamond sold as lab grown must be clearly disclosed as such, on the report, on the tag, and in conversation. If a seller is vague about origin, that is the problem, not the stone.
A Simpler Way to Decide
Rather than asking which diamond is better, ask which of these sounds more like you:
- "I want the largest, finest stone my budget allows."
- Lab grown will get you further, often considerably further.
- "I want something that holds its worth and can be traded up or passed down."
- Natural is the one with a secondary market behind it.
- "I care that it formed in the earth."
- Then that is your answer, and it does not require any further justification.
- "I mostly care how it looks on my hand."
- They look the same. Buy on budget and cut quality instead.
There is no wrong answer here. There is only the one that matches what you actually want, which is a conversation worth having in person.
See Them Side by Side
The fastest way to settle this is to look at both under the same light, in the same setting, at the same price point. Come into our Saint James showroom and we will put them next to each other and answer whatever you want to ask, with no push in either direction.